Skip to main content
  • BevNET
  • Nosh
  • Taste Radio
  • Nombase
  • CPG Jobs
  • Ask AI
  • Newsletter
  • Join Slack
  • Podcasts
BevNET CPG Media Logo
User Avatar

Subscription:

Sign Out Manage Account
User Avatar

Subscription:

Sign Out Manage Account
Login Become an Insider

Search across the BevNET CPG Media network including BevNET, Nosh, Brewbound, Taste Radio, Nombase and CPG Jobs.

Results open on cpgmedia.com

Features

  • Brewbound Live: Dec. 9+10
  • Award Nominations
  • Jobs
  • Beyond Beer
  • Big Beer
  • Craft
  • Distribution
  • Data
  • M&A
  • New Products
  • People Moves
  • Podcast
  • Voices
  • PR
    back
    • Beer Companies
    • Supplier & Service Provider
  • Supplier News

Resources

  • Videos
    back
    • Brewbound Live Replay
      Replay Strategic Business Presentations
    • All Videos
  • Newsletter
    back
    • Free Sign Up
    • View Archive
  • Submit
    back
    • Submit News
    • Brewbound 2026 Awards
      Submit Your Nominations
    • Annual CPG Awards
      Submit Your Nominations
    • Submit Beer Event
  • Directories
    back
    • Brewery Database
    • Marketplace
    • Nombase CPG Directory
    • Brewbound Awards
    • Supplier & Services Guide
  • About
    back
    • Media Kit & Advertising
    • About Brewbound
    • Contact Us
    • Team
    • Charter Members

Account

Login
  • Settings
Become an Insider
  • Brewbound Live: Dec. 9+10
  • Jobs
  • Podcast
  • Data
  • M&A
  • Newsletter
  • PR
  • Submit News
  • 2026 Awards
BrewboundPress Releases

Federal Lawsuit Challenges TTB Ban on Vintage Labels for Cider and Mead

PRESS RELEASE posted by Phillips Reynier Sumerfield Cline & Smith, LLP

Jan. 9, 2026 at 10:24 am

XLinkedInRedditFacebookEmail
Report Press Release
Beer Companies
Spokane, WA — [January 6, 2026] — Garden Path Fermentation, a beer, cider, mead, and fruit wine producer based in the Skagit Valley, Washington, joined by a consumer plaintiff, today filed a federal lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington challenging a federal rule that prohibits these producers of cider, mead, and fruit wine from listing "vintage" years on their labels.

The lawsuit targets regulations enforced by the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) that allow grape wine producers to state the year of harvest on their bottles, while categorically barring the same truthful information on cider, mead, and fruit wine labels—even when the statement is accurate and non-misleading.

According to the complaint, the rule violates the First Amendment by suppressing truthful commercial speech without evidence of consumer harm and without a reasonable justification. The plaintiffs also allege that the rule is arbitrary and capricious under federal administrative law.

"Vintage information is basic agricultural information," said Justin Leigh, counsel for the plaintiffs. "Consumers understand what a vintage year means, regardless of whether the product is made from grapes, apples, or honey. There is no rational basis for the government to allow this information for grape wine while censoring it for other wine products."

Leigh brings extensive firsthand experience in the cider, wine, and beer industries. A former owner of Dwinell Country Ales, a Goldendale, Washington–based producer that brewed beer and produced wine and cider, he is also the owner and farmer of his own cider fruit orchard, giving him direct experience with agricultural production, harvest variability, and the importance of vintage information to both producers and consumers.

In addition to his industry background, Leigh has been involved in prior litigation challenging restrictive alcohol regulations. He previously facilitated litigation against the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission involving brewery self-distribution, in which Garden Path Fermentation was a plaintiff, and he is currently counsel in a federal constitutional challenge against the Washington State Liquor and Cannabis Board concerning direct-to-consumer sales restrictions imposed on out-of-state distilleries. That case, which alleges that Washington's statutory scheme unlawfully discriminates against interstate commerce and violates constitutional protections, is on appeal before the Ninth Circuit.

"Having worked as a producer, farmer, and attorney in this space, I've seen how these rules affect real businesses and real consumers," Leigh said. "This case is about transparency, free speech, and treating cider, mead, and fruit wine with the same respect afforded to grape wine under federal law."

The lawsuit highlights a striking inconsistency in federal regulation: cider, mead, and fruit wine containing less than 7% alcohol by volume are regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which does not require pre-approval of labels and permits truthful vintage information. Once those same products exceed 7% alcohol, however, TTB prohibits vintage statements altogether. The plaintiffs are seeking declaratory and injunctive relief to prevent TTB from enforcing the vintage prohibition against cider, mead, and fruit wine producers. They are not seeking damages.

The case is Garden Path Fermentation, LLC v. United States, Cause No. 1:26-CV-3002, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington.
Brewbound Insider

Stay Informed, Stay Competitive

Unlock the articles, expert interviews, and data reports that power the beer and beyond industry. Join our community and stay ahead with exclusive insights from Brewbound.

Get Started

Already an Insider? Log In

Industry Marketplace

Secure Your Variety Pack Line Time for Your Beverage Brand - Contract Manufacturing Partner

Secure Your Variety Pack Line Time for Your Bevera...

  • View All
  • Post a Listing

Latest News

Insider’s Week in Beer: 😳 Jim Beam, You Doin’ All Right?

Insider’s Week in Beer: 😳 Jim Beam, You Doin’ All Right?

Hemp Industry Say ’50/50′ Odds Protection Bill Passes Congress During Lame-Duck Session

Hemp Industry Say ’50/50′ Odds Protection Bill Passes Congress During Lame-Duck Session

SPONSORED POST
Hop Water: What Breweries Should Consider Before Scaling Up

Hop Water: What Breweries Should Consider Before Scaling Up

Featured Jobs

Head Brewer - Beer Church Key West

Head Brewer - Beer Church Key West

Brewer - Cerebral Brewing

Brewer - Cerebral Brewing

Brewer - Victory Brewing Company

Brewer - Victory Brewing Company

Head Brewer - La Quinta Brewing Company

Head Brewer - La Quinta Brewing Company

Southwest Sales Manager - Keg Logistics

Southwest Sales Manager - Keg Logistics

Machine operator and Brewer - Solid Press LLC

Machine operator and Brewer - Solid Press LLC

  • View All Jobs
  • Post a Job

Additional News

Industry-Wide Rationalization Expected to Continue; FMBs & Craft Leading Share Losses Across Channels

Industry-Wide Rationalization Expected to Continue; FMBs & Craft Leading Share Losses Across Channels

Massachusetts Craft Brewers Outperform US in Volume Trends

Massachusetts Craft Brewers Outperform US in Volume Trends

Boston Beer COO Phil Hodges Promoted to CEO; Jim Koch to Remain Executive Chairman

Boston Beer COO Phil Hodges Promoted to CEO; Jim Koch to Remain Executive Chairman

Beer Institute Calls For ‘Consistent’ Messaging on Beer as Consumers Seek More Social Occasions

Beer Institute Calls For ‘Consistent’ Messaging on Beer as Consumers Seek More Social Occasions

Jobs in the Beer Industry

  1. Head Brewer - The Tipsy Bison - The Tipsy Bison
  2. Shift Brewer - Fall River Brewing - Fall River Brewing
  3. Shift Brewer - Russian River Brewing Company - Russian River Brewing Company
  4. Lead Brewer - No-Li Brewhouse - No-Li Brewhouse
  5. Staff Brewer - WeldWerks Brewing Co. - WeldWerks Brewing Co.
  6. Sales Representative - Obec Brewing - Obec Brewing
  7. Territory Sales Representative- San Diego, CA - AleSmith Brewing Company - AleSmith Brewing Company
  • View All Jobs
  • Post a Job

Promoted PR Posts

Spiritless Refounds Brand With National Total Wine Expansion and New Non-Alcoholic Espresso Martini

Spiritless Refounds Brand With National Total Wine Expansion and New Non-Alcoholic Espresso Martini

FlavorSum Identifies Cultural Shifts and Flavor Experiences Shaping 2027 Food & Beverage Innovation

FlavorSum Identifies Cultural Shifts and Flavor Experiences Shaping 2027 Food & Beverage Innovation

Meet RAB MAX: Real American Beer Enters High ABV With 8% Flavored Beer Line

Meet RAB MAX: Real American Beer Enters High ABV With 8% Flavored Beer Line

Private Equity Group Acquires Licksy Alcohol-Infused Lollipop Formula

Private Equity Group Acquires Licksy Alcohol-Infused Lollipop Formula

Madre Mezcal Announces National Partnership with Total Beverage Solution

Madre Mezcal Announces National Partnership with Total Beverage Solution

Donna’s Pickle Beer Takes the Plunge on ABC’s Shark Tank This Wednesday

Donna’s Pickle Beer Takes the Plunge on ABC’s Shark Tank This Wednesday

  • View All
  • Post a PR

Recent Articles

  • Newswire
  • Features
  • Spirits
  1. Food and Drink Recalls Face a 2027 Shake-Up
  2. Martignetti Companies Completes Acquisition of Girardi Distributors
  3. Orchid Island Brewery Expands Operations, Highlighting Florida’s Indian River Citrus with Progressive Grove to Glass Beers
  4. BERO Puts A Crisp New Twist on Bestselling Shandy Collection with Limited-Edition "Big Apple" Flavor
  5. Ekos Launches Co-Packer Portal, Giving Contract Brewers and Beverage Producers a Live Client View of Every Run
  1. Insider’s Week in Beer: 😳 Jim Beam, You Doin’ All Right?
  2. Hemp Industry Say ’50/50′ Odds Protection Bill Passes Congress During Lame-Duck Session
  3. Press Clips: Brewery Openings, Closures and a People Moves
  4. Industry-Wide Rationalization Expected to Continue; FMBs & Craft Leading Share Losses Across Channels
  5. Massachusetts Craft Brewers Outperform US in Volume Trends
  1. NA Wine, Functional Drinks Lead Growth in Total Wine’s $75M Adult Non-Alc Set
  2. Owl’s Brew Rebrands, Doubles Down on Spiked Pop
  3. RTD Distribution: Moves From Owl’s Brew, Livewire, Anytime and More
  4. Brown-Forman US RTD Director Talks Expansion Plans
  5. Spirits Marketing: Tito’s Rots, Johnnie Walker Taps Oscar-Winner, Stateside Refreshes
  6. Maryland Revises Distribution Rules for RTDs
  7. Lewis Hamilton’s Almave Laps Into RTDs
  • View All
  • Submit News

Brewbound

Contact

  • Advertise with Brewbound
  • Submit News
  • Submit a Beer Event
  • Post a Job Listing
  • Contact Us

Follow

  • Newsletter
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Youtube

Resources

  • About Brewbound
  • BevNET.com
  • Taste Radio Podcast
  • BevNET Magazine
  • NOSH
  • Nombase

Navigate

  • News
  • Events
  • Breweries
  • Craft Beer Jobs
  • Craft Beer Events Calendar
  • Industry Marketplace
  • Videos
BevNET CPG Media Logo

Brewbound is a part of BevNET CPG Media. All rights reserved (Terms & Privacy Policy) © 2016 - 2026.

Contact Us
  • BevNET
  • Nosh
  • Brewbound
  • Taste Radio
  • Nombase