[00:00:00] Justin Kendall: Next on the Brewbound podcast, find out what life is like for LA's only cidery. Hello and welcome to the Brewbound podcast. I'm Justin Kendall.
Jessica Infante: I'm Jessica Infante, and
[00:00:22] Zoe Licata: I'm Zoe Licata.
[00:00:23] Justin Kendall: And this week, Zoe has survived a, well, last week you survived a travel nightmare trying to come back from the Beer Institute.
[00:00:32] Zoe Licata: Honestly, we got out lucky by only one of us getting hit by that insane travel. I don't even know what you would call it at this point.
[00:00:40] Justin Kendall: When did you get home?
[00:00:42] Zoe Licata: I got home Saturday night, was initially supposed to be back Friday night. It was like 24 hours later than it was supposed to. But yes, I was supposed to leave DC from the Beer Institute events on a flight Friday night. That flight got canceled. Well, first delayed and then was eventually later that night canceled due to the SAA chaos and grounding of all planes and was initially going to take a flight the next day and then that next day that flight got canceled. So I ended up. On the train, which was lovely, but an 8 hour train ride.
[00:01:19] Justin Kendall: Oh my God, I was just going to ask you how long that train ride is because I've never done that.
[00:01:23] Zoe Licata: Yeah, I mean, it was pretty. We got to see the entirety of. I think we went through like, yeah, we went through a lot of states, but it was lovely. Crazy. We're going past New York City when it was like prime sunset. So that was pretty nice.
[00:01:41] Justin Kendall: What a great argument for high speed rail.
[00:01:45] Zoe Licata: Yeah. Yeah, there are usually options for slightly faster. I think you get 6, a little over 6 hours like in a cellar, but not that weekend when everyone on earth is trying to get out of DC or whatever else they are. It was a little wild.
[00:02:04] Justin Kendall: What were the people drinking to sort of make them forget that they were stranded and grounded and Maybe never leaving.
[00:02:13] Zoe Licata: I never made it to the airport, so I can't tell you what the airport experience was. I'm sure there was a lot of domestic loggers, or whatever the local craft beer was going through for everyone who was stuck there for hours and hours. We were fueled by Guinness, but yeah, it could have been a lot worse. We heard some nightmare stories out of folks being stuck on planes for hours and hours, and that kind of stuff, so, kind of got off a little easy.
[00:02:39] Jessica Infante: I think you're rivaling Justin for travel mishaps this year. Between this and your Seattle
[00:02:44] Zoe Licata: trip. Yeah, it really hit me. I've been cruising, no real major issues, and then 2026 just decided to be a pain in my ass.
[00:02:55] Justin Kendall: You made my delay coming back from Irvine at the California Brewers Association meeting just look like nothing. Getting home at 12:30, I'll take that over being stranded.
[00:03:05] Zoe Licata: Yeah, I mean, there are worse places to be stranded than DC I guess. Especially when we live, or I live in Boston, cause we had a lot of options. If it got real desperate, we'll find a car somewhere, just make that drive, which would have been the same amount of time as that train, if not maybe 30 minutes faster.
[00:03:25] Justin Kendall: Let's talk a little bit about this week's featured guests, and they are from Benny Boy Cider in Los Angeles. Give us the lowdown, Zoe. This is an interview that you did.
[00:03:34] Zoe Licata: Yeah, really excited to have Chelsea and Benny from Benny Boy Cider on. I met them at CiderC this past February in Providence, Rhode Island, and got to talk to them about their cidery that's based in Los Angeles. They claim to be the only Los Angeles-based cidery. They're both a brewery and the cidery. And they do a lot of really fun stuff at their location in LA. A lot of cool events. They have an annual fall festival where they kind of try to bring the classic New England or Pacific Northwest apple orchard fall feel and tradition to Los Angeles for a lot of folks who are either have never experienced before or they're transplants, and they missed that in LA. And so we had a really awesome chat about Both those events as well as just how they're creating a Benny Boy community and introducing folks to cider who may not be into it, never tried it, or think they don't like it through things beyond just the products themselves. So yeah, lovely chat with those fine folks.
[00:04:39] Justin Kendall: Well, after the folks hear your interview, and they love it, and they come to Brewbound Live on December 9th and 10th. They can swing over to Benny Boy.
[00:04:50] Zoe Licata: Yeah, absolutely. We're gonna be in Los Angeles for Brewbound Live, December 9th and 10th, and I would highly recommend, if you're coming to town, head over there, see what they have going on.
[00:05:03] Justin Kendall: Get your tickets to Brewbound and then make a stop over at Benny Boy. Let's get into the news of the week, and we got a handful of stuff that we should probably hit. Should we start with heavy seas and their bankruptcy? Because I, I feel like they obviously hit a rocky spot here. There's a lot going on with this story beyond just their own chapter 11 bankruptcy. You got some information from them, Zoe.
[00:05:30] Zoe Licata: Yes, like you said, there is a lot going on here. We saw that they filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy. They are being very adamant that this is not a liquidation process that they're looking for. They are trying to find a way to sustain the brand, sustain the brewery, and it's just not something that they can do with their current financial situation. So I got some more details from Caroline Sisson, who has been kind of like their de facto communications and leadership person. Since her father Hugh Sisson is trying to get into retirement, his next chapter of retirement. So that's another piece of what is happening here, cause you announced, you know, he's, he's gonna retire, he's going to step away. This is something that he already had started doing earlier this year, and he's going to continue to see them through this process of what their next chapter is, but, you know, he's in his 70s, he's ready to to go and relax and get away from the business side. The third element here is that when he initially announced that he was stepping away, it was because Heavy Seas was pursuing this business deal or partnership with B3 Beverage, which was that craft platform that we've talked about quite a bit on the podcast and on our website. And they didn't actually end up going through with that deal. That was something they chose not to go forward with, it didn't work out. They're not the only craft brewery to pull away or step away from their dealings with B3 as they are going through their own. Lawsuit process and a lot of complicated dynamics going on there. So yes, there's a lot of elements happening within this story, but I think the biggest takeaway here is, you know, heavy seas, it's got a lot of debt, it's got a lot of these unsecured claims they claimed within their filing are for. You know, debts of they had deals with partnerships for supplies and things, and they were kind of on a, all right, we'll pay you back type situation, and they were never able to follow through on those debts. And so now they need to actually be able to pay those partners. And so this step is figuring out how they're going to do that, how they're going to pay those partners, and then potentially find a new place for the brand to to exist under. So it's kind of a waiting process to see what happens with that. And you know, is there going to be someone who comes in and and purchases the brand or like can take over ownership now and after they go through this process, we don't know, but they're being super transparent about, you know, we're going to communicate what happens. There's definitely going to be changes, but we're going to try as best as possible to keep the brand going and keep staff employed and keep the brand as it exists for however long it exists in the way that it is.
[00:08:15] Jessica Infante: They are Maryland's largest craft brewery right now after the acquisition of Flying Dog. A six pack of heavy seas Loose Cannon is one of my first. Like 6 packs. Like it was one of my first like craft beer purchases that I can remember. Like I walked into the Total Wine in my town and picked it up because I was swayed by pirates, I guess. And I brought it home and didn't quite understand. Well, who's not exactly? Didn't quite know what IPA really meant and I was kind of like, Oh, I don't know if this is for me. But yeah, I grew out of that and look
[00:08:50] Zoe Licata: how far you've come.
[00:08:51] Jessica Infante: Now I enjoy an IPA here and there.
[00:08:54] Zoe Licata: Yeah, they're huge and I mean, they're not only are the largest crap brewery, but they're also like double the size production wise of the second largest. Like they are. Massive in that state. This is brewers Association defined craft in that state.
[00:09:13] Jessica Infante: I didn't realize there was such a disparity.
[00:09:15] Zoe Licata: Yeah, so that's a lot of volume, a lot of beer that now is kind of up in the air. But as I said, Carolinea's very adamant, you know, we are planning for this to emerge out of this process still in existence.
[00:09:30] Justin Kendall: And it's not just them. It's been tough times for a lot of Maryland craft breweries. I mean, we look at what happened with Diagio shutting down the Open Gate brewery there. We look at FX Mad acquiring Flying Dog, as you mentioned. There's another piece off the board. I don't believe they have any presence in the state anymore. So, I feel like it's been just really hard times for that state. I think they're a little bit like mass in that they don't allow chain sales off-premise for the most part. I think they had a bill come up maybe last year to change that. Yeah, tough hit for Kraft. The B3 fallout is interesting. I think we're going to continue to see ripples of that.
[00:10:12] Zoe Licata: Yes. And Caroline said, you know, that the decision to file for bankruptcy did not have to do with the B3 move. So they're saying, you know, this was kind of something separate. But yeah, everything going on with B3 was definitely not anywhere close to being over. Hey listeners, this November 17th roundup brings lots of new beer jobs to CPGjobs.com, including from Sunboy and Alvarado Street Brewer. Brewery, Alesmith Brewing, Owl's Brew, and Serene Craft beer distributors add more hot openings from great companies. Beer people, chase them now in the brewbound news you already read. Need talent on your team? Post your job today at CPGjobs.com. Appear beside Brewbound's daily beer business news and reach brewers, sales leaders, and distributor staff. Post the job at CPGjobs.com. Use code brewbound 26 and save money on a job listing. Quick break from the Brewbound podcast.
Beer and beverage alcohol have never been harder to navigate. So who's figuring it out? Leaders from Sierra Nevada, Allagash, Firestone Walker, and New Belgium for starters. They're speaking at Brewbound Live, December 9th and 10th in LA, and teams from Athletic Brewing, Deschutes, Russian River, and Whole Foods Market are already registered. Register at Brewboundlive.com.
Justin Kendall: Let's transition and talk about the Lone Pine, Lord Hobo Valterra Partners situation because that's another one that, I mean, this was our most read story of the last week, not to give away too much here, but I think people are very interested in anything to do with Lord Hobo drama.
Jess Infante: For sure. So we got a tip months ago now about a lawsuit that was entered into Massachusetts Superior Court that I just kept Checking and checking and checking, and then finally the complaint showed up and it was heavily redacted. But all we could see for weeks was that Lone Pine was suing Lord Hobo. If you remember, Lord Hobo acquired Lone Pine just about exactly 2 years ago in a deal that was funded by Valterra Partners, who props up Lord Hobo. And at the time, leadership was really optimistic and enthusiastic. They were going to become a craft centric platform for regional power brands and they wanted to add a lot more breweries and maybe even beyond beer, and they had all of these big ideas and it made sense here and there. And then over the spring, I believe, maybe it was like late April or May. They decided to stop production at Lord Hobo's large brewery and shift to complete contract out of Isle Brewers Guild in Rhode Island. Also made sense. And then this lawsuit hits and what you can see is that Lone Pine's founders allege that they have not been paid a single cent for their brand in over 2 years in a bunch of different payments that were supposed to be made. There were just transitional payments. There were payments due after core brands were produced. There was a spirits earnout for their spirits business, and they said that they didn't see any of that money at all. Now the lawsuit was so redacted, so we don't know what. The dollar amounts are, but you can kind of tell that they're at least 7 figures. I would say maybe even to 8, like tens of millions. But again, completely redacted and not in the way that various government agencies were redacting last year where you could just easily copy paste into a different document. These are, these are legit redacted and I couldn't tell. We reached out to both sides. Nobody wanted to comment, which is a given, and we'll see what happens. But the Lord Hobo team, like all the advisors were named in this lawsuit under the Massachusetts Region Apply Defense, which allows somebody who's seeking to recoup damages to also extend that to anybody who may be able to claim any money from a certain company. In this case, it would be Lord Hobo. Lone Pine is applying all of that and We'll see how it gets resolved, but it's like a Hallmark holiday movie somehow where like a private equity backed firm. Convinces two childhood friend craft brewers who opened their brewery because of their passion for craft beer, promises them all of this, and then gives them nothing. Not to oversimplify it, but that's what I kept thinking about when I was writing it, like there's almost It's so cliche writes itself, but hopefully it works out for everybody. Yeah, yeah, I mean, we'll be tracking it, and I, I think that's about as far as we can go. Look for more. We'll be looking for some outcomes here. The platforms, they do be falling apart.
[00:14:47] Zoe Licata: Yeah,
[00:14:48] Justin Kendall: I mean that strategy, it seems so promising, and then it just seems like there's just too many underlying issues with various partners to get any of these deals in a sustainable place.
[00:15:02] Zoe Licata: Yeah, the tough thing with so many of those platforms was that they were built with breweries that were already in kind of a tough situation. And so it's an enormous task to try to operate those businesses. And then when you're doing it with multiple and though you have just a complicated back end of everything, like we're bound to see some of these eventually not work out. But yeah, it appears we have now reached that time.
[00:15:29] Justin Kendall: It's really unfortunate. Let's get to the big distributor deal of the last week, and that's AB1 has acquired some of the assets, probably most of them, of Straub Distributing in Anaheim. It's a more than 9 million case outfit. Obviously, Anheuser-Busch being the primary desire here for AB1, but they're pretty much locking down their Southern California territory, which is the main thing. They did the advanced deal. In Bakersfield, they already have LA and San Diego, so they're connecting a lot of the dots there, and I think my eye is sort of on what comes next. They've got all the territory or pretty much their footprint there in Southern California locked down. What do they do next? Do they keep it? Do they move it on to Southern Glazers? Is that a market that Southern Glazers is interested in? I don't know, but It seems like maybe that's the direction this heads. I don't know, that's just speculation on my part.
Jessica Infante: Well, I mean, all bets are off, right? The consent decree expired and they no longer are beholden to that 10% volume cap of their product flowing through their own wholly owned distributors. So who knows what will happen.
Justin Kendall: And they're in the midst of looking for a CEO, so they're in that type of transition where Maybe nothing gets done for a little while, but they certainly have got something across the finish line here. Yeah, I mean, AB1 has been doing different things here and there. Like for a while, it looked like they were selling off anything they could, and then sometimes they would do something a little funny where they would buy brand rights like they did up in Washington state a couple of years ago, but I think you're right. They clearly are lining things up in Southern California. Yeah, and they've already, I believe they already routed their spirits-based offerings to Southern Glazers in California, right?
Jessica Infante: They did. I don't know.
Justin Kendall: Put my tin foil hat on here, but that might be where this is heading. With that, we should probably get to our featured interview with Benny Boy.
[00:17:43] Zoe Licata: Our next guest, I had the pleasure of meeting at CiderCon this year, and I'm very excited to finally introduce to you all. Joining us now is the co-founders of Betty Boy Brewing. We have Chelsea Rosetter and Benny Farber. Welcome you guys.
[00:17:57] Speaker 3: Thank you. Thanks for having us.
[00:18:00] Zoe Licata: Yeah, so excited to have you on and chat about all things in the cider scene and in your beer scene. For anyone who is unfamiliar, give us the elevator pitch. What is Benny Boy all about?
[00:18:12] Speaker 3: Benny Boy is really about having a great experience, and we've put that first, so we do a lot of events and themed parties at Benny Boy. But it all boils down to having a good time with quality craft beverages that we produce here, and that's beer and cider. We have a lot of guests that like one or the other and both. So it It's really about appealing to everyone and creating a space that everyone feels comfortable in and has something that they like to drink.
[00:18:43] Zoe Licata: You guys are based out of Los Angeles, which I feel like folks aren't super familiar with what the cider scene might be like there. You might think of like the Pacific Northwest or something. So what is that consumer like in that cider culture like?
[00:18:57] Speaker 3: Yeah, it's definitely an education project for introducing people to cider, because a lot of people are not aware of what it is, or they're also accustomed to the big commercial brands that are very sweet and a little cloy, and so, People come in, they go, Oh, I don't like cider, and we go, Well, why don't you just try a little taster here and see if that changes your mind. And it has really opened people's eyes, and people have been blown away with the fact that cider can be very balanced and delicious without giving you a, a horrible headache the next day. You know, I was into cider years before we opened this, and I wanted to do it, and, you know, early before we opened the laws, we weren't sure that we could pull it off, but When we did open, the laws did change to allow us to make cider here with a wine license, but it was really about just bringing multiple options to the table for people and not, not just being the beer side where, you know, not everyone, you know, we imagine people getting in a, a bunch of friends getting in a car, and let's go to Benny Boy, and while one person might be gluten intolerant or somebody made it just not like beer. But when you offer the beer on one side, the cider in the cider house, and we also offer wine and NA beverages, we're trying to just appeal to everyone to come and and have something that they like. Yeah, but I think also, as you're mentioning Los Angeles, we're the only cidery in the city of Los Angeles, so we have this amazing opportunity to introduce people to a beverage they've never had, especially craft cider. So people are walking in, they can get a flight of cider, they can try 4 different varieties, they can talk to us about apples. So it is a smaller community and it's growing, but people are excited. Our cider is our largest distribution product over beer because there's a lot of craft beer and there's not a lot of craft cider. So we get to see maybe the first LA cider people have tried at a restaurant. Or a bottle shop. So that's really fun to be here and to surprise people. You're bringing them in, but cider is like, Oh, this is exciting. Let me try this, or I'm not sure I like that. And we're like, just try a sample. Just, just have a try. And then for those, those that like both, we offer snake bites, which is, you know, half cider, half beer. So it's also an adventure because they can go to either the brewery on one side of the property and fill their pint halfway, and then they have to go over to the cider house to get the other half. Uh, so it kind of makes it a, a little adventure, and, uh, and snake bites are really awesome.
[00:21:33] Zoe Licata: Yeah, yes, we're big fans over here of a snake bite. Yeah, it's fascinating. We talk about all the time, at least like in our day to day, about California's craft scene. It's just one of the densest and consumers are still super excited about craft there. So, the idea that, oh, cider hasn't quite cracked it yet, and you guys have that opportunity to be kind of the first ones to get in there is, is such an awesome market to, to have access to.
[00:22:01] Speaker 3: Yeah, honestly, I'm surprised there's not any other ones yet producing in the city of LA, but it's all about exposing people, and, you know, in the next two weekends, we have our Apple Fest, which is a huge cider event for us. I built an 1,800s style cider press based on what I saw in London. So we, we get volunteers to help make cider on this old press where you people have to get on both sides and crank down the wheels to push the juice out. So, you know, last year we had 800 volunteers to help. And then, you know, when the cider is ready, if they volunteered, they get to come in and get a free pint. For the cider that they helped make, so, you know, it puts a little ownership into it, and then people also can better understand the process of how cider is made because a lot of people just don't understand how it's made. So they see that and they go, Oh, I get it, and then it goes into a tank and then it's just add yeast. So it creates a lot of fans of cider that people may not have known about before. And so it's, it's all part of educating and growing the cider awareness. And our momentum is growing. When we opened 5 years ago, we were 75% beer sales, 25% cider, and we're almost at 50/50 now. So we're really proud of that. Our cider house is much smaller than our brewery, and we joke someday we're going to have to swap buildings because We're just, we're focused on it. We're the only ones doing it, so we're super passionate. We have an actual cider tree from our orchard where we get our apples inside the cider house, so people ask a lot of questions. It's just, it's a fun exploration. And people are looking for fruity stuff. They're looking for low ABV stuff. Cider's a wine, but it's a low ABV wine. They're looking for sugar-free, so cider's this like awesome category, and it appeals to guys and gals equally. So it's one of the most gender balanced of all of the craft beverages. So it's super welcoming. And I think Ben was talking about that before, but having the beer and the cider, it creates this awesome atmosphere of bringing together maybe wine folks and beer folks in one beer garden to party and hang out. So, it's not just traditional craft beer atmosphere, it's got another layer. And, you know, people are also always on the look for something new and different. And I think that resonates with them because it's not beer, but it's still a craft beverage, and the apples we get are sourced from Central Coast. They're all California apples, they're heritage cider apples. The quality is, is there, and I think people are, are tasting that. I think it's fun to pitch cider to people that have never tried it, because usually we can make a connection of something they love and know. So like, our tropical ciders appeal to hazy drinkers, our botanical ciders appeal to cocktail lovers, the funky stuff that's barrel edge is like great for natty wine folks. There really is a cider beverage for all the palates, and people are like, oh, I'm not a fan of that one, but this one is my jam, so I think people underestimate that about cider as well, and beer has that too, for sure, but I think the flavors of cider, the spectrum of cider surprises people. It's very versatile in terms of flavors that go with it.
[00:25:15] Zoe Licata: Yeah, 100%. I am constantly telling folks, just go to a cider event one time and just sample the variety of ciders and just see, like, it is so vast, it's incredible. A lot of folks' first introduction to cider isn't seeing that experience, so it's a lot of education still. Yeah. I'm happy you brought up the pressing because that is something that really stuck out to me when I first met you all is when you're telling me about that is you, you guys are providing these experiences and these events for folks to come to your spot and experience everything and, and participate in it. Walk us through like why it was important for you to have an event like that. How did you decide we're gonna actually like have folks come and and make cider with us? This is something I think is worth doing.
[00:26:03] Speaker 3: We noticed people in the city. I mean, we are minutes from downtown, we're adjacent to Dodger Stadium. We're right by the 5 freeway. We're in the city, but people will, during the fall, want to go drive 3 hours to go to an apple orchard and wear their flannel and their sweaters and be cozy and have mulled cider and have this crisp fall experience and have seasonal flavors, and we're like, what if we just brought the orchard to the city? And Ben was like, I can make an apple press. And so he did. It looks like a torture chamber device to a lot of people when it's out at the beer garden and they're like, What's that? What's that? What's that? And we're like, wait for Applefest. You're gonna love it. So it's a way that we can invite the feeling of harvest season and the feeling of fall right into LA. And last year it was raining all weekend and we were so worried no one was going to come, and people came and they're like, it's fall. This is like, it was actually a bonus. Like it was a part of being cozy. They were huddled and waiting to press apples in the rain, and it was so magical and we have a jazz band on, and it was just like, we did it. We brought That sort of feeling to the city. So I think that's what's when we figured out Ben was going to make the press, and then the second part was like so many questions about what is hard cider, what's cider? What is the difference between apple juice, you know, in the states we call cider is non-alcoholic. So being able to show people like how it used to be made and how it used to be made. If you had a farm and you had apples, and you had a press, and then translating that to, it's not cider yet, but this is the fermentation process. So the whole time we have Angelenos sorting apples that came from the Central Coast, they're asking about the different varieties, they're seeing the different colors, they're pressing on an old fashioned press, and And then we get to talk to them and show them our tanks. It's going in here. We're going to add some yeast, and then it's going to come out and be this amazing beverage and try last year's Community rush. So we call the whole pressing a community rush, and then a few months later, it comes out in a bottle, and it comes out on draft, and it's, come and try the cider you helped make. It's a fun full circle moment and people can bring their friends. I helped make the cider last year at the fall festival when it was raining. So it's just, I think that's the long story.
[00:28:11] Zoe Licata: Yeah. No, it's awesome. It's, I mean, so we're based in New England over here, we're used to that culture of just, that's what you do every fall. You go up to the orchard and you, you go pick some apples, or you do whatever. So I can see this, the appeal for wanting that and creating that, but the Los Angeles
[00:28:28] Speaker 3: way. I mean, we were both from the country, we did stuff like that. And we wanted to bring those experiences to the city because not everyone is gonna drive 3 hours to go experience that. Why not drive 5 minutes and have it available to you here? Yeah. There also are a lot of transplants that come and they're like, oh my gosh, I used to do this. And then there's a lot of Angeline like who grew up here and like, I never would have occurred to me to go and have this fun fall thing, and here I am doing it in a brewery.
[00:28:56] Zoe Licata: Yeah. And you guys are doing tons of other events throughout the year. I mean, you look at your calendar, there's so many fun things going on. I'm very jealous. How are you deciding what kind of events are right for you, and just what's your, your strategy when it comes to events for Betty Boy?
[00:29:13] Speaker 3: I think our strategy at the beginning was be different, go big. So we have a big beer garden, we have big ideas. If we're gonna do karaoke, we're gonna do live band karaoke. If we're gonna do bingo, we're gonna do chicken chip bingo. If we're gonna put on these things that are recurring that people love, how do we put a spin on it? And then we've made up festivals, we've made up holidays, which people are surprised and delighted by. And then you get to know your customers. So I think now we're sprinkling in stuff that we know is going to hit in our neighborhood, you know, you learn after 5 years what really is fun for people, but we also just want people to have, like Ben said before, have fun. Come try some cider. Don't think about it too hard. It's not fancy. We serve all of our cider in these apple wine glasses from Germany that are, they're not stemware. They are a little. Little grandmay, which is fun, and it feels like a pint, like it feels like a beer. We didn't want cider to be an overwhelming thing for people to adopt or unapproachable, as in like stemware and all, you know, we want it to be fully approachable because it's not a hoity-toity drink. It's just fermented apples, and it's America's first alcoholic beverage that was made. And America was huge into cider before prohibition, and that really just killed it. And so it's a slow creep back from that. The more people are aware, the more they realize cider can be very good. It just depends on who's making it.
[00:30:46] Zoe Licata: I have to ask because you brought it up, Chelsea, can you explain to folks what chicken shit bingo is?
[00:30:52] Speaker 3: Yes, and this is another example of us bringing the country to the city. Ben built another part of this event. He built the coop. So we call it the poop coop, and it has numbered squares on the bottom of the coop, and we have different farm partners or pals that have urban farms that bring their chickens over, and guests pay per square to bet on where the chicken is going to poop. And we're playing country music. Literally everyone is in cowboy hats and gear. Sometimes we do line dancing, sometimes we've added cowboy. karaoke. We've done live country bands. So it's kind of our western day once a month through the summer. Our cousin Matt, who's our MC for the event, discovered this in Austin, Texas. This was before we even opened, and he's like, you guys have got to do chicken chip bingo. And so the fact that we did it and we launched it is pretty, it's fun. It's, it's a lot of fun. We put bales of hay around the beer garden. We like to transform into these different experiences, so it's our western day.
[00:31:55] Zoe Licata: My small farm town of Massachusetts used to do, they called a cow pie bingo, similar preference, just a cow, a bigger board. Yes, much bigger board, but people, I mean, you're into it. You are just like. Hanging out all day, yeah, you're waiting for it to be your square. You want it to be your square, yeah, people get really jazzed about it. So yeah,
[00:32:19] Speaker 3: I've never seen so many adults so excited to see an animal, you know, do their business.
[00:32:25] Zoe Licata: Exactly, yeah, who would have thought,
[00:32:27] Speaker 3: yeah.
[00:32:28] Zoe Licata: It's funny that cider, I think especially like craft cider, has a bit of a pretentious reputation when most cider folks are like farmers who are, you know, like very low key, just chill, down to earth folks. So yeah, it's totally a different experience, I think, than than its reputation. What is your process of deciding, all right, this is like an event we should do, or or something that's like, OK, this is, this is a Betty boy thing.
[00:32:57] Speaker 3: The initial decision is, will it be fun and engaging? Will people feel like it resonates? Do they relate to it? And so, we try to keep it within the expectations of Angeleno's and, you know, we're not gonna get wacky and wild about some crazy event that nobody can understand. One event we just made up was Watermelon fest. Just watermelon-themed cider, beer, watermelon seed spinning contest, and it hits. I mean, who doesn't like watermelons? So not getting too existential about it and just making it so it feels like a party, you know, our original idea was, you know, the beer garden is, we also call it our backyard, and we want everyone to feel like they're at our friend's backyard barbecue. And that's the atmosphere that we try to create is you feel at home. At Benny Boy, because it feels like you're at somebody's backyard. Yeah, we also have a lot of dog lovers in LA in California in general. And so we've done a few dog events that were really fun, and Ben made a racetrack. So we have, for the Kentucky Derby, we do a corgi Derby. So some of these things we do come up with and we're like, people might not come. This is like really silly, and we're just going to throw it out there, especially the first few years, and people came and they were curious, and they're like willing to play these fun games with us, and we have roll out the track and it's the cutest race ever with their little butts running. And it's not competitive. It's super, it's for the entertainment value, exactly,
[00:34:33] Zoe Licata: just a little goofy and fun, yeah,
[00:34:35] Speaker 3: yeah, it is highly entertaining, yeah, and I think these days, as we know, people aren't going out as much, so they need an assignment. What am I gonna wear? I can wear my hat to the corgi derby. I can have a mint julep cider. I can watch some dogs run around, and I can take amazing Instagram photos. So like, I think giving people an assignment and themes, theme night. What do your customers love theming and tonight, like that has been really fun and successful for us.
[00:35:02] Zoe Licata: Yeah, I think, yeah, what you just said is a super key resource that some companies have been starting to figure out you can use, because we talk about constantly, like, one of the biggest buzzwords recently has been occasions and like finding ways to create occasions for folks. And at first I think that strategy was OK, how can I create a product that is meeting the occasion that already exists? And now in just the state of folks just trying to figure out where is my place in socializing, what is my place in society look like, actually giving them the occasion first and then saying, hey, you can also have some of these products while you're doing it, it's an amazing opportunity.
[00:35:42] Speaker 3: I love that you brought that up because I think we call them rituals at Benny Boy. So we have like a list of 15 rituals that we just look at and we refresh and we're like, which ones are the best. Ben developed a calamansi cider for, we have an amazing, uh, Manila Sound backyard disco party once a month. And so we're like, have a calamansi cider at Manila Sound, have mulled cider. When it gets cold out at Krampus, have the snake bite journey from the side of your house. We've converted an old ski, if you've heard of shot ski, and we put beer pints on it so people at weddings will do a, a beer ski. So a brewski, sorry, I thought it was a brewski, but that's a ritual, or we have the cos wheel at Oktoberfest time. I don't think people are necessarily drinking less, they just want a ritual to do it or an occasion to do it for instead of just on their own. Yeah, and, you know, another aspect is we do cider slushies too, and those are heavy hitters. People just go nuts over them.
[00:36:43] Zoe Licata: The slushy phenomenon is so interesting to me because like on the surface you think, I, do I want this in a slushy form, but everyone I've talked to that has some sort of like a slushy beer or a slushy cider, they're like, this is one of our most popular things. That experience of just having it in a slushy form clicks for folks.
[00:37:02] Speaker 3: It really, and it surprised us. Like everyone was asking for it, so we were like, you know what, we gotta try it, and we're the only ones doing the cider slushies. When it's hot out, you want something frozen, and I guess that's just the truth. Yeah.
[00:37:20] Zoe Licata: So you're balancing all of these incredible events along with just keeping your business going and growing over these past few years. Do you have any advice or tips for folks that are looking to maybe up their event game? How do you manage that? Is there any like lessons you've learned in, in building up that calendar, or just what is key to make sure it's gonna be the right sort of event for, for your own business?
[00:37:45] Speaker 3: So we have a really extensive project management timeline for each event. So this isn't just like this weekend, this is what's happening, we're planning months ahead. So, you know, right now we're trying to plan all of the beginning of, you know, the half of next year. So I think planning ahead is key. We've recently hired an on-site events manager, so that's been really helpful. Those are like kind of nitty gritty, but in general, you have to be into it. And I think you have to make it your own, because there's so much repetition of regular nights and competition that other people are doing it. So, I think we try to just make it a little weird, you know, we can't always, sometimes it's just, it is what people like, but I think you have to be in it to sell it to people, and then you have to market it. We have a great team that is making silly videos, we are putting out content. If you don't tell the people, they won't come. So I would say if you're gonna do events, you have to have a marketing plan to back it up, or it'll be a lot of work for not a lot of payoff. Another one of our policies is, you know, we don't half-ass it, so we decorate for events. We hang flags, we hang banners, we doll it up for the theme. You can say, oh, it's Oktoberfest, and if you don't decorate it at all, it's like, well, does this feel like Oktoberfest? The feeling needs to be evoked with the theme of the party. So that's the other thing is don't half-ass it. You have to go all in. Otherwise people aren't gonna come back. Don't underestimate transforming your space.
[00:39:20] Zoe Licata: Yeah, I mean, there's nothing worse than going to an event and like thinking it's gonna be a certain type of vibe, and then it's just kind of lacklustering and kind of
[00:39:28] Speaker 3: weak, you know, and you're like, OK, well, I'm gonna go somewhere else for the next Oktoberfest or whatever it is. So we try to incorporate a wow factor because if people aren't impressed, they're not coming back for that next event. And I think you have to build that trust. So it might not be the first time you do it, but people are going to remember that when they went, everyone was dressed up and they weren't. Now they trust you. OK, the crowded Benny Boy dresses up, so I'm not going to feel silly if I go there in my costume because I'm going to be surrounded by people that are having a lot of fun who look amazing. I think the more they come, the more people, the more they meet our crowd. We're so excited that they're so excited about some of this stuff. So like, and our whole staff dresses up, we dress up. Like it's just kind of setting the bar that like, if we throw it out there, I hope you're not disappointed.
[00:40:21] Zoe Licata: Amazing. While we have you on here, I wanted to also get your perspective on, I mean, you talked about how insanely large your cider business has grown from just the beginning. We talk a lot that cider has been having a kind of different experience than other beverage, alcohol or beer segments right now. It's finding growth. It's connecting with consumers. What is both of your opinion on just why cider is still having this moment? Why is it finding a way to connect that maybe other segments aren't right now?
[00:40:52] Speaker 3: I think cider is so welcoming and so approachable when you give it a chance, and it appeals to both genders equally. It's staying with the times if people want to know what's in their beverage, so a classic craft cider is going to be just apples and thyme. Once you learn that, it's like, OK, this isn't going to make me feel like crap in the morning. It's lower ABV than wine that I might be grabbing. It's fruity. It's tropical. It's hitting all these buckets of what people are looking for in a beverage these days, and it's supporting usually pretty local farmers. It's also apples can be dry farmed, which is much more sustainable than grapes, than grapes, it's much more sustainable. I think that cider hits on a lot of these things that people are searching for in a craft beverage. And once they find one that they love, they're like, oh yeah, cool, this is cool, I like this. Yeah, you know, there are still plenty of people that don't like beer, and this is an alcoholic beverage that has a broad appeal, and it's relatively new, quote unquote, in the, uh, the craft beverage scene, and I think it's an exciting new category that people are being made aware of and going, oh, I could get into this. I mean, Full disclosure, we started this, and, you know, I was home brewing and making beer all the time and a beer fanatic. As we've progressed through the years here, I am almost entirely drinking cider instead of beer. I just love it. We have multiple staff members who've had the same journey and are now totally. Gone from craft beer obsessed to craft cider obsessed, so it's not a far reach, and I think they both are so social, and I think it's just that Even people who love beer could have a few and want something lighter, and ciders there, and it's carbonated, it's crushable. You can put it in a wine glass for dinner, you can bring it to the beach in a can. It's just this fun in between sort of. I think it lives between wine and beer so well, which is a really cool tasting event with a winery where it was a flight of 4 wines, cider included. The flight was a transition from Trying ciders into trying grape wine with some co-ferments in between and some co-ferments in between. That's right. That's right. So it was a straight cider. It was a co-ferment Chardon apple, so Chardonnay and apple. It was a rose cider. So we had Pinot Noir and an apple. Variety blend, and then it was a straight white wine. And people who came, I think their minds were a little bit blown that they were like, oh, cool, I get it. I totally get why if I love this, I'm gonna love this. And the conference is another really fun way to get people kind of buying in and snake bites. Like those are like, if you like this, let's mash it up and try this other thing, but they all kind of live in this cool spectrum.
[00:43:51] Zoe Licata: So, we're looking ahead, I know you have your fall fest coming up and everything. What else are you all looking forward to for Benny Boy and, you know, about to enter into 2027?
[00:44:01] Speaker 3: What we're looking forward to is getting more of our product out to Los Angeles. So, we're gonna hire another salesperson and really push the distribution out there. We're gonna shoot to double our distribution. It makes people more aware when there's a cider, a local cider available, and then they're more likely to come in and, and check out the place too. So, yeah, for us, our big push next year is getting it out more into Los Angeles. Nice. We want there to be a time when local restaurants are looking at their local wines and their local beers, and then their local cider. So we really believe that cider can fit on that local wine menu, and that it's really fun to have a, like, two blocks away option to throw on there. So, that's what we're looking forward to.
[00:44:46] Zoe Licata: Yeah. Incredible. Well, I can't wait to see what else comes from you folks, but I really appreciate you coming on and chatting. Thank you again.
[00:44:55] Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you so much. Yeah, I appreciate it.
[00:44:58] Justin Kendall: And that's our show for this week. Thank you for listening. The Brewbound podcast is a production of Bevnet CPG. Our audio engineer for the Brewbound podcast is Joe Cratci. Our technical director is Joshua Pratt, and our video editor is Ryan Gilang. Our social marketing manager is Amanda Smerlinsky. Our designer is Amanda Huang. If you enjoyed this episode, please share it with your colleagues and friends and review us on your listening platform of choice. You can find our work at brewbound.com. And we also welcome feedback and suggestions at podcast@brewbound.com. On behalf of the entire Brewbound podcast team, thank you for listening. We'll be back next week.